Marvel's Top 100 (ranks 5-1)
5. Rachel Grey/Summers ~ Phoenix/Marvel Girl/Prestige

Created by: Chris Claremont and John Byrne and John Romita Jr
First Appearance: Uncanny X-Men (1963) #141
Sometimes my hope for a character supersedes their actual execution. I recently saw Rachel on a list of worthless X-Men characters. And truly, I understand the perspective. Yet whenever I look at the character, all I see is promise, promise mis-used but promise nonetheless. As you can see in her listed name, Rachel's been tried and redone a number of times, and she has one of the more convoluted stories in an X-Men world that is known for being convoluted. Still none of this dissuades me from ranking her as my highest (true) X-Man.

Rachel is the hope of the X-Men intertwined with their despair. The child of Cyclops and Jean Grey from a history no longer real, she is first met emaciated in a mutant concentration camp in the far future. The sentinels have taken over and the world is broken. Humanity has won and thus lost. Little is revealed about Rachel beyond her power to send an old Kitty Pryde back into her body in the early 80s to stop the assassination of Senator Robert Kelly. If aspects of this sound familiar, this is because the event as well as the movie they loosely based upon it were titled The Days of Future Past. The assassination is obstructed, history is changed, but Rachel finds that she changed the history of another world. Thus Rachel has saved a world, only not hers.
Years later, she would risk everything to use her powers to send herself physically back in time to this alternate dimension which she had saved from her future. Yet Rachel bears all the emotional agony and even physical scars of this world she fled. The child of the first and best students of Xavier's, Rachel should have been the first generation of Xavier's Dream: instead she lived Xavier's nightmare. As the lore of her life expands and her history unfolds, the reader learns after witnessing the destruction of the X-Men as a small girl, she was brainwashed and used in the future for her telepathic gifting to be a Hound, hunting down fellow mutants. Her face branded as a possession of monsters.
So now she has to find a place in a world that feels like a fleeting dream. Scared to hold on to anything in fear of losing it, as she always has before. Her first go around with the X-Men would end in tragic downfall. She would leave the team dying from Wolverine gutting her to keep her from killing another. (Good job, Wolvie...) All of her pain and anxiety causing her to break down amidst the strain of life.
Through the help of... well, not friends, Rachel would survive Wolverine's evisceration and get whisked to the pages of the newly formed Excalibur, wherein, Rachel would begin to realize the hope into which she was born.

In these pages, she is able to form lasting friendships and grow out of the fearful child gifted freedom for the first time in her life.
Her convoluted history bears even more bizarre twists and turns after Excalibur (Mother Askani, anyone?), but I assume most would consider her Excalibur days the high point of her Marvel existence.
In recent years, Rachel has actually been getting pretty heavy use, sitting on many of the X-Men teams, however she has had little to no character movement in the pages I have read. So it seems like Marvel has an awareness of her potential, keeping her around presumably at writers' requests. Yet there is still this uncertainty of what is next for her. Well, it is the promise of who she could be that ranks her here.
Recommended Reading: Excalibur (1988) #1-50
4. (Kid) Loki

Created by: Matt Fraction and Pasqual Ferry
First Appearance: Thor (2007) #617
First, to clarify who I am ranking, while I can enjoy the villain Loki, I am specifically choosing here the Loki who is reborn after the event Siege published in 2010. In the comics, Loki had written himself out of the rebirth cycle of Asgard and thus his brother Thor took it on himself to bring Loki back. Only, this Loki was different. He was still a small boy with many of the giftings of the God of Mischief but not yet the evil and malicious tendencies.
But how does a world trust the person who has betrayed them time and time again? How can they ever befriend or care for one who has stabbed them in the back since time immemorial?
Yet repeatedly, the child Loki is tasked with saving the Realm Eternal and all the other worlds besides. Yet his powers are not powers of might, but of the tongue; lies and deceit are Loki's tools of war. So when the world needs saving, Loki must twist and wind a tale of treachery in order to accomplish noble deeds.

Essentially Guillen's run of Journey into Mystery is a long account of Loki attempting to pay for something now, with a promise of later. Attempting to put off the bill coming due, he dances between conflicting forces, while never owning an ounce of trust amongst his "friends." It is an expertly crafted story with a captivating twist on a villain turned hero.
The emotional toll of a boy who means well but has the wrong skill set for being a hero is a deeply affecting story. He was a character with a short publishing life, but in that span, he captured my heart.
Recommended Reading: Journey into Mystery (2011) #622-645
3. Jamie Madrox ~ Multiple Man

Created by: Len Wein and Chris Claremont and John Buscema
First Appearance: Giant-Size Fantastic Four (1975) #4
Jamie Madrox had a long but not very full publishing life before his character bore much relevancy. Created in 1975, he would get little notice until his first time on an X-Factor team in 1991. Peter David played him as a prankster. And while David gave Madrox a bit of depth regarding his power to duplicate himself, it would be years still until Jamie got the development that would launch him into being one of the more dynamic Marvel characters in existence.

It would be Peter David again returning to the character, first in a Madrox mini-series that stirred enough interest to make a new ongoing X-Factor series. In these books, David would fulfill one of the best examples of the psychological implications of a characters super power upon their mind. As Jamie Madrox is the Multiple Man and can see and do all options he is paralyzed into choosing nothing. Madrox actually begins to try to live his life as a film noir, to give it structure and control. Seeing a scripted noir life as boundaries and safety.
What is more, his dupes (duplicates) begin bearing random different parts of his personality, causing no sense of reliability in any dupe formed. Testing his capacity to fulfill any of the things required of him due to his special capabilities.

An early letter to X-Factor accused Madrox of being a terrible main character, having no direction or assertiveness. Obviously that is viewing the book from the more common expectation of super hero comics that present an idealization of who we want to be, rather than who we are. I find Madrox deeply compelling in his new definition of self conflicted.

As the series unfolds, you see Madrox confronted with all of his failings; sometimes he rises to the occasion, sometimes he sinks to the bottom. But David keeps the character's pathos intact throughout, deftly using the bizarre and impossible of the comic world to explore real human experience.
I am almost happy that Marvel killed him off after David concluded his story so that no one else would bother him... Though I suppose I would have preferred something like what DC did with Robinson's Starman, keeping him sacred ground that no one else could touch.
Recommended Reading: X-Factor (2005) #1-50, 200-262
2. Ben Urich

Created by: Roger McKenzie and Gene Colan
First Appearance: Daredevil (1964) #153
I assume at this point, I can't shock you, but maybe this does: my second favorite Marvel comic character is not a super hero. He has never worn tights. He has been beaten, but never beat up a villain. My second favorite Marvel character may be the most heroic on the list. If heroism is sacrifice, Ben Urich has had to make some of the hardest choices in the Marvel world: choosing good over safety, good over wealth, good over himself.

An investigative journalist, Ben was able to uncover the secret identity of Daredevil. Only he decides to sit on this story (his Pulitzer he calls it) for the sake of saving Matt Murdock. Yet throughout Daredevil's stories, he is beaten, stabbed, brought into a world that is so far beyond his mortal ken. Having no physical defense against the dangers of a world with Kingpins and Elektras, Ben Urich has to choose the good, knowing full well what it could cost.

What is courage when you have the powers of a ninja? What is courage when your only weapon is a typewriter? Ben is tested and tried in the pages of Daredevil and proves himself a hero in ways sometimes more striking than the name on the cover.

Ben is the human that proves superhuman, not through powers of might but through compassion.

Recommended Reading: Daredevil (1964) #227-233, Daredevil (1998) #16-19
1. Dani Moonstar ~ Psyche/Mirage
Created by: Chris Claremont and Bob McCleod
First Appearance: New Mutants Graphic Novel (1982)
Here she is, number one in my rankings: may I introduce you to Danielle Moonstar. Why Dani? Well, first let me point you back to a few threads that have danced through this list. You may have noticed a number of young mutants. Clearly a realm of comics I am drawn to are the students of the X-Men world. The why of that is abundant, but let me stay on topic here. You may have also noticed some dissatisfaction with how those characters grow up in comics. I enjoy them in the school environment but writers often fail to take them to the next step (or at least the step I envision). Well, simply put, Dani is the exception to that rule.

She began in the pages of New Mutants as the angry minority character that unfortunately was overused with Native American X-Men characters (not saying they did not have reason to protest). But while it takes time for her to learn trust, her independence and strength becomes a rock for the New Mutants to rest upon. Much of this develops in the New Mutants golden period, where Dani attempts to battle her demons, which in this case have a physical form as well as spiritual, called the Demon Bear. Initially confronting the demon alone, she learns the value of her friendships as it is they who save her. As the book continues, she quickly matures into the class's co-leader, alongside Cannonball; submitting her needs to those of her friends'.
The X-Force book takes a turn towards worth reading once Dani rejoins her friends, immediately finding a role of leadership again. An otherwise forgettable restart of New Mutants was saved by Dani taking a counseling role for new young students at Xavier's. She continually makes books better when she appears, seemingly through force of will. Oh, did I mention she becomes a Norse Valkyrie?

If the New Mutants were the next generation of X-Men, Danielle was their brightest star. She perhaps did not bear the hope of Cannonball, but she had the grit and the fire. In the coming years, writers would twist her powers and even remove them, but her fierce leadership and spirit could not be deterred. It is striking that she led a mutant team without herself any longer being a mutant and no one, most especially the reader, ever thinks anything is amiss.
If they had developed likewise, I am certain Sam and Rahne would be playing around in the top 5 as well, but due to what has been done with them, Dani wins out. And I am okay with that.
Here she is, number one in my rankings: may I introduce you to Danielle Moonstar. Why Dani? Well, first let me point you back to a few threads that have danced through this list. You may have noticed a number of young mutants. Clearly a realm of comics I am drawn to are the students of the X-Men world. The why of that is abundant, but let me stay on topic here. You may have also noticed some dissatisfaction with how those characters grow up in comics. I enjoy them in the school environment but writers often fail to take them to the next step (or at least the step I envision). Well, simply put, Dani is the exception to that rule.

She began in the pages of New Mutants as the angry minority character that unfortunately was overused with Native American X-Men characters (not saying they did not have reason to protest). But while it takes time for her to learn trust, her independence and strength becomes a rock for the New Mutants to rest upon. Much of this develops in the New Mutants golden period, where Dani attempts to battle her demons, which in this case have a physical form as well as spiritual, called the Demon Bear. Initially confronting the demon alone, she learns the value of her friendships as it is they who save her. As the book continues, she quickly matures into the class's co-leader, alongside Cannonball; submitting her needs to those of her friends'.
The X-Force book takes a turn towards worth reading once Dani rejoins her friends, immediately finding a role of leadership again. An otherwise forgettable restart of New Mutants was saved by Dani taking a counseling role for new young students at Xavier's. She continually makes books better when she appears, seemingly through force of will. Oh, did I mention she becomes a Norse Valkyrie?

If the New Mutants were the next generation of X-Men, Danielle was their brightest star. She perhaps did not bear the hope of Cannonball, but she had the grit and the fire. In the coming years, writers would twist her powers and even remove them, but her fierce leadership and spirit could not be deterred. It is striking that she led a mutant team without herself any longer being a mutant and no one, most especially the reader, ever thinks anything is amiss.
If they had developed likewise, I am certain Sam and Rahne would be playing around in the top 5 as well, but due to what has been done with them, Dani wins out. And I am okay with that.
Recommended Reading: New Mutants (1983) #18-34, New Mutants Special, X-Men Annual #9

Comments
Post a Comment